Your Best Customers Deserve More Than a Generic Newsletter
Your loyal, high-spending customers drive 80% of your profits. So why are you treating them the same as first-time visitors?
Sarah has bought from your Shopify store 47 times in the past two years, spending over $3,200. This morning, she received the same "30% off everything!" email as someone who's never purchased before. How do you think that made her feel? Special? Valued? Probably not.
The VIP Customer Reality
Your top 20% of customers generate 80% of your revenue, yet 73% of brands treat all customers the same in their marketing. Stores with dedicated VIP experiences see 67% higher customer lifetime value and 45% better retention rates.
The Cost of Treating VIPs Like Everyone Else
When you send your best customers the same generic newsletter as everyone else, you're not just missing an opportunity—you're actively diminishing their perception of your brand. VIP customers don't want to be treated like everyone else because they know they're not everyone else.
What Generic Marketing Does to VIP Customers
- Makes them feel undervalued despite their loyalty
- Suggests you don't know or care about their purchase history
- Creates a "commoditized" relationship instead of a partnership
- Encourages them to shop around since they're not getting special treatment
- Reduces emotional connection to your brand
- Wastes the opportunity to increase their already high lifetime value
Understanding Your VIP Customer Segments
Not all VIP customers are the same. Through customer segmentation, you can identify distinct types of high-value customers, each requiring a different VIP approach:
The Four Types of VIP Customers
The Consistent Loyalist
- Profile: Regular purchases, predictable timing, steady AOV
- Value: Reliable revenue stream, low maintenance
- VIP Approach: Consistency rewards, early access, appreciation
The Big Spender
- Profile: High average order value, quality-focused, less price-sensitive
- Value: Highest revenue impact, premium positioning
- VIP Approach: Exclusive products, white-glove service, luxury experiences
The Brand Evangelist
- Profile: Active on social, leaves reviews, refers friends
- Value: Marketing multiplier, organic growth driver
- VIP Approach: Behind-the-scenes access, co-creation opportunities, referral rewards
The Growth Potential
- Profile: Increasing purchase frequency/value, showing VIP potential
- Value: Future high-value customers, growth opportunity
- VIP Approach: Gradual VIP introduction, loyalty building, value demonstration
Creating VIP Experiences That Matter
VIP treatment isn't about giving bigger discounts—it's about creating experiences that make your best customers feel valued, understood, and special. Here's how to design VIP experiences for each segment:
VIP Email Marketing Strategies
The Consistent Loyalist Experience
- Early access to new products (24-48 hours before general release)
- Restocking alerts for their favorite items
- Quarterly appreciation messages with usage insights
- Exclusive loyalty rewards and points bonuses
The Big Spender Experience
- Exclusive product lines and limited editions
- Personal stylist or product specialist access
- Premium packaging and white-glove service offers
- Invitation-only sales and private shopping events
Beyond Email: Creating a Complete VIP Ecosystem
VIP treatment extends beyond email marketing. It's about creating a comprehensive experience that makes your best customers feel special at every touchpoint:
Customer Service VIP Lane
- Priority customer support queue
- Dedicated support representative who knows their history
- Extended return/exchange policies
- Proactive issue resolution based on purchase patterns
Exclusive Access Programs
- Early access to sales and new products
- VIP-only product lines or colorways
- Behind-the-scenes content and brand updates
- Input on product development and feedback sessions
Surprise and Delight Moments
- Unexpected free gifts with orders
- Handwritten thank you notes
- Birthday and anniversary recognition
- Exclusive experiences (virtual events, tutorials)
Measuring VIP Program Success
VIP programs should drive measurable business results. Here are the key metrics to track:
Customer Lifetime Value
+67%
Average increase for VIP programs
Retention Rate
+45%
Better retention vs generic treatment
Referral Rate
+156%
More referrals from VIP customers
Implementation: Your VIP Program Roadmap
Phase 1: Identify Your VIPs
- Analyze customer data to identify high-value segments
- Create VIP criteria (LTV, frequency, advocacy, etc.)
- Segment your VIP customers by type and behavior
- Set up tracking for VIP metrics
Phase 2: Design VIP Experiences
- Create segment-specific email sequences
- Design exclusive offers and experiences
- Set up VIP customer service protocols
- Plan surprise and delight moments
Phase 3: Launch and Optimize
- Launch VIP program with announcement to qualified customers
- Monitor engagement and satisfaction metrics
- Gather feedback and iterate on experiences
- Expand program based on results and learnings
The Lumino VIP Advantage
Lumino's customer segmentation automatically identifies your VIP customers and reveals the specific behaviors that make them valuable. Our platform helps you understand not just who your VIPs are, but what motivates them, when they buy, and how to keep them loyal.
Related Articles
Continue learning with these related insights and strategies
Ready to Treat Your VIPs Like VIPs?
Your best customers drive 80% of your profits. Discover who they are and create experiences that keep them loyal forever.
Join stores building lasting relationships with their most valuable customers